[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Good boots for awhile, but then the lining gave way and it trapped my foot like a finger trap. I almost had to cut it off.

Tried 2 pair. They both were amazing for about 6 months, after which the inner lining/footbed came detached from the sole of the boot. Bought the 2nd pair and they did the same thing. They are super comfortable but they just aren't holding up. The boots look barely used, but have already suffered major structural failure.

The top part of boot is pretty wide which makes putting them on/off super easy but makes putting pants over them difficult unless they have a generous boot cut . Not a big deal if you tuck your pants into your boots . Love the heel stepper on the back makes taking them off so easy and doesn't ruin the heel of the boot like my last pair ended up doing . I like carhart but the carhart tag logo is overkill on these boots, something less pronounced would be preferred like a subdued logo? as in there is already a carhart logo molded into the black rubber near the bottom. I'll probabaly end up cutting the carhart tag off . Make sure to measure your feet their size 10.5 is other brands 9. So far comfortable and no need for insoles .