We have two senior female cats (almost 15 years old) and they're picky eaters. I bought a bunch of different food and then kept notes about what they liked and what they didn't. The Paws & Claws Supreme Supper made it to the list of 5 or 6 different cans that they like. So we continue to give them this food and watch them enjoy it.

My cats love this brand of wet food

DO NOT BUY THIS CAT FOOD. I had been feeding this cat food of various flavors for awhile. I hadn’t noticed and issues with it until today. I opened a can of this exact flavor, and while putting it in my cats bowl I found a large piece of black plastic/rubber that looks like it broke off of a machine during processing. I poke through the can some more and found other smaller fragments of the same material. This typically wouldn’t be something for me to gawk at. This is a very cheap food, and so I simply threw this particular can out. But I figured I should give the company (that is through tractor supply) a call and inform them that they have plastic pieces breaking off into their food because that’s not good. I called the number on the can, i was put on hold for what I was told would be 3 minute wait. But then the automated system told me that no one could take my call and i would have to leave a message and someone would call me back after waiting for about 15 minutes on hold. I left a message with my issue and my name and phone number, and after a couple days I still never got a call back. I called again and got the same thing. So as a consumer I don’t feel very heard or cared about by the company. Im sure this was a one off thing with this can, but what if it’s a recurring quality control issue that they don’t know about? We shouldn’t be selling cans full of plastic bits for cats to eat. And if you’re gonna have a phone number for people to ask questions or voice concerns, maybe answer it when people call. Assuming i won’t get a call back, i will be taking this can and the plastic pieces to the store I bought it from and hopefully the store will at least refund me for a contaminated can. Again I’m more upset about the lack of customer service for the phone line that actually finding plastic in the food as I could again just remove the plastic or throw the full can of food away which is no biggie. But to have no over the phone support is wild.

Barn cats love! Even though they bring me every critter around the barn, they are picky eaters. But, the barn cats love this cat food. They are in every night for it.