I've gone through so many of these. My dog loves them. They are easy to use. But only last two-three uses... four at the absolute most. They definitely are not the same durability as the red version dog treat dispensers. The dog can chew through the rubber with ease unlike the competition. Now if they could combine the two - that wold be a winning product!! The included picture is of the 3 that I have kept. From left to right: 4 plays; 3 plays; just 2 plays.

Perfect toy. Our little guy is obsessed. Amuses him for literally hours

The new and improved harder rubber pupsicles are worlds better than the older ones. This was a genius idea and now it’s a genius product. An indispensable tool for any dog owners!

I want to start out by saying that I would love to give a 5 star rating because my dog loves the pupsicles . However, the design of the holder is impossible to use. After the first use I haven’t been able to screw it together and find extremely difficult to unscrew when done. I have oiled the threads and rinsed after use but still find it difficult to use. I would like to know if you have other types of holders?