Muck Boot Company Men's Realtree Edge Arctic Ice XF Boot Vibram Arctic Grip A.T.

I had high hopes for these boots. They look nice and are super comfortable. The first time I wore these, I was working in a vault with a minimal amount of water around the ankle, and they kept my feet dry. The second time that I used them it was with water roughly up to the middle of my calf. Both of my feet were soaked as if I was just walking in water with no protection. I did a close visual inspection and noticed that the stitching around the gusset wasn't the best quality and thought they must be wear the water was coming in. So, I filed a claim and they sent me a new pair. This new pair looks pretty much the same with the stitching around the gusset. I decided it would be prudent to do a test in a bucket full of water before I went into the field this time around. Same result, I put the boot in water about half way up the gusset and water is seeping in. This is the same with 2 other coworkers who have this same boot. Very disappointed, I would not recommend using this in any water environment. Might be fine for snow and mud, but I think anyone who buys these boots has the expectation of these being waterproof.

My daughter bought me the just a little over a year ago. They do not get worn everyday Mabe 5-6 times a month if that. Very disappointed my wife has other styles and there great, but these are a disappointment.

Best boots I've ever had to be honest. But to be far i so live in the country were these are basically required to live here

These boots are by far the best I have owned .... on the ice, in snow or woods these take care of me. Would recommend!