Twisted X Men's Chukka Driving Moc Shoes, MDM0072-M-07

I bought these as a gift for my son in law. He loves his first pair. I ordered him a new pair in the same size different color than what he has. The shoes are huge. Box and shoes say 9.5. They looked big in the box and when he put them on they are definitely way to big…more like an 11. He will be returning them. He liked the ones he had so well my daughter also ordered him a third color. His original shoes at 9.5 fit great, the ones I ordered were way to big, the third pair of 9.5 my daughter ordered are to small! Three drastically different fits for the same shoe, maker, style and size yet the sizing is way off on each! A slight difference can be accepted but these differences make the shoes unwearable. Will have to return them and will not take a chance on ordering them online again!