I purchased a pair of these in a different color 4 months ago. They fit great with a warm pair of socks and keep my feet warm in 20 degree weather. I always add a new arch support insole to all of my muck boots. I would give them 5 Stars for fit and usefulness. The traction is great for my use. I can not evaluate how they wear as I have only had them a short time. My other Muckster Ankle boots have lasted over 6 years with every weekend use and are finally wearing out. My 3 star is based only on color. I have been waiting for this olive/brown/orange colorway to be back in stock as for several months. They finally were but when they arrived the color was so much different than the picture. Very dark and the sole is not orange but a muddy tan. All other boots I have ordered from Muck Boot Company have been very similar to the picture on line. Sadly I'm sending them back - not for fit but color. Very disappointed!

I’m overall pleased with the materials and warmth of the boot but disappointed in the sizing/fit. For the price, I would expect more accurate sizing and fit comfort. I sized down and the boots are still too big. My long socks are always pulled down by the boots which is really bothersome. I have to wear two pairs of thick socks to avoid this issue which is not comfortable. I wouldn’t buy these again unless the fit is changed.

I am a big fan of all Muck products. I have the chore boots, which are great, even in the snow. The ankle high boots are great in the garden, especially in our very wet climate in Oregon. They are waterproof adn well insulated, plus great traction, even in mud. I am particularly grateful for the big loop at the back of the boot, because I take them on and off frequently (going in and out of the house).

The women’s arctic short boots are just what I needed. They are durable and comfortable.