Skip to main content
HalloweenPetLawn & GardenTruck & AutomotiveSporting GoodsHorseFarm & RanchClothingLivestockPet & Animal PharmacyToolsPoultryFencing & GatesHome ImprovementOutdoor LivingHeating & CoolingHome Decor & FurnitureOutdoor Power EquipmentTrailers & TowingBoots & ShoesWild Birds & WildlifeToysGift CardsServices Propane RefillTrailer RentalGarden CenterFeed CenterSame Day DeliveryPetVet ClinicPet WashGrooming at PetsenseDog Training at PetsenseTractor Supply RxPet InsuranceWag!

"Savings and Offers"

Weekly AdSaleClearance

"More Options"

Weekly AdWhat's NewTractor Supply AppEarn Rewards with Neighbor's ClubHometown HeroesLife Out Here BlogTSC Exclusive BrandsTop BrandsClearance ItemsBattery FinderOutdoor Power Equipment Parts FinderHitch Finder

Spend $49.99 to unlock Free Delivery on most orders

|
Learn More
Order statusTSC Credit CardsWhat’s newPetsenseWeekly Ad
​

Sign In / Enroll

Get rewarded!

​
Menu

Search

Home

Sign In

Cart
5.0
(8)
5.0 out of 5 stars. 8 reviews
A woman outside with a dog
A woman outside with a dog
  1. Home
  2. /
  3. Clothing
  4. /
  5. Men's & Women's Accessories
  6. /
  7. Jewelry
  8. /
  9. Earrings
  10. /

  11. Montana Silversmiths Star Lights First Star I See Tonight Earrings

  1. Home
  2. /
  4. /
  5. Earrings

Montana Silversmiths Star Lights First Star I See Tonight Earrings

Shop all Montana Silversmiths
Montana Silversmiths Star Lights First Star I See Tonight Earrings

Item # 121051399

Montana Silversmiths Montana Silversmiths Star Lights First Star I See Tonight Earrings
Montana Silversmiths Montana Silversmiths Star Lights First Star I See Tonight Earrings
$45.99

Spend $49.99 to unlock free delivery!

Get everything you need
Montana Silversmiths Star Lights First Star I See Tonight Earrings
5.0(8)

Montana Silversmiths Star Lights First Star I See Tonight Earrings

$45

.99

Montana Silversmiths Heart's Flame Opal Necklace, NC5873
5.0(1)

Montana Silversmiths Heart's Flame Opal Necklace, NC5873

$70

.99

Montana Silversmiths Northern Lights Mystic Topaz Stone Stud Earrings
5.0(2)

Montana Silversmiths Northern Lights Mystic Topaz Stone Stud Earrings

$45

.99

Neighbor's Club logo
Neighbor’s Club Members earn points with purchases.

Sign in or Join Now

Shop all Montana Silversmiths
Montana Silversmiths Star Lights First Star I See Tonight Earrings

Item # 121051399

Montana Silversmiths Montana Silversmiths Star Lights First Star I See Tonight Earrings
Montana Silversmiths Montana Silversmiths Star Lights First Star I See Tonight Earrings

$45.99
financeCard Logo
New Cardmembers earn a $20 Reward‡ with qualifying purchase of $20 or more plus earn 5% in Rewards+ on this purchase. Valid through 8/9/26.

Spend $49.99 to unlock free delivery!

This item is available online only

Delivery to

Free standard delivery on online footwear & Clothing purchases of $49 and over.

​
Get everything you need
Montana Silversmiths Star Lights First Star I See Tonight Earrings
5.0(8)

Montana Silversmiths Star Lights First Star I See Tonight Earrings

$45

.99

Montana Silversmiths Heart's Flame Opal Necklace, NC5873
5.0(1)

Montana Silversmiths Heart's Flame Opal Necklace, NC5873

$70

.99

Montana Silversmiths Northern Lights Mystic Topaz Stone Stud Earrings
5.0(2)

Montana Silversmiths Northern Lights Mystic Topaz Stone Stud Earrings

$45

.99

Neighbor's Club logo
Neighbor’s Club Members earn points with purchases.

Sign in or Join Now

Bring some classic style to your look with the Montana Silversmiths Star Lights First Star I See Tonight Earrings. These post earrings are as bright and bold as the stars in our own Big Sky country. Featuring a bold, round, solitaire crystal stone set in bright silver finish, these classic earrings are made to shine.

Limited Lifetime warranty on Manufacturing Defects

  • Classic, stud Montana Silversmiths earrings
  • Cubic zirconia offers these stud earrings a fashionable flair
  • Hypoallergenic stainless steel posts offer comfort
  • Rhodium plated over a brass base offers durable shine
BrandMontana Silversmiths
Country of OriginImported
Backing TypeTension
Earring DesignStud
Earring StyleFashion
Earring TypeGeneral earrings
FinishE-Coat
Gemstone TypesCubic Zirconia
Hanging Length0.5 in.
Number Of Charms0
Number Of Diamonds0
Number Of Gemstones2
Package Quantity1
Primary ColorGray
Primary MaterialBrass
WarrantyLifetime
Manufacturer Part NumberER2545
No questions have been asked about this product.

No questions have been asked about this product.

Q&As

No questions have been asked about this product.

No questions have been asked about this product.

Similar Items

  1. Montana Silversmiths Star Pendant Earrings, Turquoise
    0.0 out of 5 stars with 0 reviews
    0.0 (0)

    Montana Silversmiths Star Pendant Earrings, Turquoise
  2. Montana Silversmiths Star's Burst Drop Earrings
    0.0 out of 5 stars with 0 reviews
    0.0 (0)

    Montana Silversmiths Star's Burst Drop Earrings

    $65.99
  3. Montana Silversmiths The Outrider Earrings
    0.0 out of 5 stars with 0 reviews
    0.0 (0)

    Montana Silversmiths The Outrider Earrings

    $60.99
  4. Montana Silversmiths Starlight Stillwater Earrings
    0.0 out of 5 stars with 0 reviews
    0.0 (0)

    Montana Silversmiths Starlight Stillwater Earrings

    $60.99
  5. Top Rated
    Montana Silversmiths Cross Post Earrings
    5.0 out of 5 stars with 1 reviews
    5.0 (1)

    Montana Silversmiths Cross Post Earrings

    $45.99
  6. Top Rated
    Montana Silversmiths Star Lights Western Princess Earrings
    5.0 out of 5 stars with 1 reviews
    5.0 (1)

    Montana Silversmiths Star Lights Western Princess Earrings

    $50.99
  7. Montana Silversmiths With Love Heart Earrings
    0.0 out of 5 stars with 0 reviews
    0.0 (0)

    Montana Silversmiths With Love Heart Earrings
  8. Montana Silversmiths Trailing Turquoise Earrings
    0.0 out of 5 stars with 0 reviews
    0.0 (0)

    Montana Silversmiths Trailing Turquoise Earrings

    $70.99
  9. Montana Silversmiths Stirrup Hoop Earrings
    0.0 out of 5 stars with 0 reviews
    0.0 (0)

    Montana Silversmiths Stirrup Hoop Earrings

    $65.99
  10. Montana Silversmiths Western Ember Earrings
    0.0 out of 5 stars with 0 reviews
    0.0 (0)

    Montana Silversmiths Western Ember Earrings

    $75.99
  11. Montana Silversmiths Turquoise Darling Earrings
    0.0 out of 5 stars with 0 reviews
    0.0 (0)

    Montana Silversmiths Turquoise Darling Earrings

    $70.99
  12. Montana Silversmiths Canyon Drop Earrings
    0.0 out of 5 stars with 0 reviews
    0.0 (0)

    Montana Silversmiths Canyon Drop Earrings

    $90.99

Items You May Like

  1. Montana Silversmiths Spirit of the Sky Earrings
    0.0 out of 5 stars with 0 reviews
    0.0 (0)

    Montana Silversmiths Spirit of the Sky Earrings
  2. Montana Silversmiths The Glamour Cut Earrings
    0.0 out of 5 stars with 0 reviews
    0.0 (0)

    Montana Silversmiths The Glamour Cut Earrings

    $70.99
  3. Montana Silversmiths Grand Geyser Earrings
    0.0 out of 5 stars with 0 reviews
    0.0 (0)

    Montana Silversmiths Grand Geyser Earrings

    $70.99
  4. Montana Silversmiths Regal Rider Earrings
    0.0 out of 5 stars with 0 reviews
    0.0 (0)

    Montana Silversmiths Regal Rider Earrings
  5. Montana Silversmiths Bountiful Blessings Earrings
    0.0 out of 5 stars with 0 reviews
    0.0 (0)

    Montana Silversmiths Bountiful Blessings Earrings
  6. Montana Silversmiths The Open Road Earrings
    0.0 out of 5 stars with 0 reviews
    0.0 (0)

    Montana Silversmiths The Open Road Earrings

    $70.99
  7. Montana Silversmiths Bridle Chain Earrings
    0.0 out of 5 stars with 0 reviews
    0.0 (0)

    Montana Silversmiths Bridle Chain Earrings

    $55.99
  8. Montana Silversmiths Sparkling Halo Earrings, ER6101
    0.0 out of 5 stars with 0 reviews
    0.0 (0)

    Montana Silversmiths Sparkling Halo Earrings, ER6101
  9. Montana Silversmiths Pure Luck Earrings
    0.0 out of 5 stars with 0 reviews
    0.0 (0)

    Montana Silversmiths Pure Luck Earrings
  10. Montana Silversmiths Out West Hoop Earrings
    0.0 out of 5 stars with 0 reviews
    0.0 (0)

    Montana Silversmiths Out West Hoop Earrings

    $80.99
  11. Montana Silversmiths Summer Rain Turquoise Earrings
    0.0 out of 5 stars with 0 reviews
    0.0 (0)

    Montana Silversmiths Summer Rain Turquoise Earrings

    $75.99
  12. Montana Silversmiths Celeste Hoop Earrings
    0.0 out of 5 stars with 0 reviews
    0.0 (0)

    Montana Silversmiths Celeste Hoop Earrings

    $50.99

Customers Also Bought

  1. Montana Silversmiths Dorado Cross Earrings
    0.0 out of 5 stars with 0 reviews
    0.0 (0)

    Montana Silversmiths Dorado Cross Earrings
  2. Montana Silversmiths Classic Allure Earrings, ER5669
    0.0 out of 5 stars with 0 reviews
    0.0 (0)

    Montana Silversmiths Classic Allure Earrings, ER5669
  3. Montana Silversmiths Golden Horizon Bar Earrings
    0.0 out of 5 stars with 0 reviews
    0.0 (0)

    Montana Silversmiths Golden Horizon Bar Earrings
  4. Top Rated
    Montana Silversmiths Luminescent Post Earrings, Blue
    5.0 out of 5 stars with 2 reviews
    5.0 (2)

    Montana Silversmiths Luminescent Post Earrings, Blue

    $45.99
  5. Montana Silversmiths Bridgerton Feather Earrings
    0.0 out of 5 stars with 0 reviews
    0.0 (0)

    Montana Silversmiths Bridgerton Feather Earrings
  6. Montana Silversmiths Classic Small Hoop Earrings
    0.0 out of 5 stars with 0 reviews
    0.0 (0)

    Montana Silversmiths Classic Small Hoop Earrings

    $50.99
  7. Montana Silversmiths Glacial Peak Earrings
    0.0 out of 5 stars with 0 reviews
    0.0 (0)

    Montana Silversmiths Glacial Peak Earrings

    $85.99
  8. Montana Silversmiths Pointed Path Turquoise Earrings
    0.0 out of 5 stars with 0 reviews
    0.0 (0)

    Montana Silversmiths Pointed Path Turquoise Earrings
  9. Montana Silversmiths Flower Rowel Earrings
    0.0 out of 5 stars with 0 reviews
    0.0 (0)

    Montana Silversmiths Flower Rowel Earrings

    $70.99
  10. Montana Silversmiths American Legends Feather Earrings
    0.0 out of 5 stars with 0 reviews
    0.0 (0)

    Montana Silversmiths American Legends Feather Earrings

    $90.99
  11. Montana Silversmiths Western Silhouette Longhorn Earrings
    0.0 out of 5 stars with 0 reviews
    0.0 (0)

    Montana Silversmiths Western Silhouette Longhorn Earrings
  12. Montana Silversmiths Lucky Harmony Earrings
    0.0 out of 5 stars with 0 reviews
    0.0 (0)

    Montana Silversmiths Lucky Harmony Earrings

    $60.99

Reviews

Rating Snapshot

Select a row below to filter reviews.

5 starsstars

8
8 reviews with 5 stars.

4 starsstars

0
0 reviews with 4 stars.

3 starsstars

0
0 reviews with 3 stars.

2 starsstars

0
0 reviews with 2 stars.

1 starstars

0
0 reviews with 1 star.

Overall Rating

5.0
3 out of 3 (100%) reviewers recommend this product

Review this Product

Select to rate the item with 1 star. This action will open submission form.
Select to rate the item with 2 stars. This action will open submission form.
Select to rate the item with 3 stars. This action will open submission form.
Select to rate the item with 4 stars. This action will open submission form.
Select to rate the item with 5 stars. This action will open submission form.
Adding a review will require a valid email for verification
1 to 4 of 8 Reviews .
1 – 4 of 8 Reviews
Sort by
Most Recent
Reviews 3
5 out of 5 stars.

Great and believable size

2 years ago
Sparkling as pic

Yes, I recommend this product.

Washington
Reviews 3
5 out of 5 stars.

Pretty

2 years ago
Love these! Very nice and pretty for the price
2023 Q4 SweepstakesYes
Tehachapi, CA
Reviews 2
5 out of 5 stars.

Gorgeous and you can wear them anywhere!

4 years ago
These are my new favorite earrings! My husband bought them for me for Christmas and I wesr them almost every day. They are just the right size and they are gorgeous!

Yes, I recommend this product.

Texas
Reviews 2
5 out of 5 stars.

A lot of Sparkle!

5 years ago
The photo doesn’t capture how these beautiful earrings dance in the light. They have A LOT of sparkle!

Yes, I recommend this product.

4 Ratings-Only Reviews

Get the top deals, latest trends and more
Sign up for emails from Tractor Supply today.
First Name*
Last Name*
Email*

Customer Support

  • Order Status

  • Return Policy

  • Delivery Options

  • Tax Exemptions

  • Frequently Asked Questions

  • Contact Us

  • Recall Notices

  • Call:  

    (877) 718-6750

  • Mon - Sat: 7am - 9pm CT

  • Sun: 8am - 7pm CT

  • Closed Christmas Day

About Us

  • Who We Are

  • Investor Relations

  • Stewardship

  • Community

  • Military Support

  • Product Catalog

  • Tractor Supply Stores

  • .Pharmacy Verified Website

Work With Us

  • Careers

  • Sponsorship

  • Affiliate Program

  • Potential Vendor Partners

  • Vendor Information

  • Tractor Supply Media Network

Neighbor's Club

  • About

  • Rewards

  • Hometown Heroes

  • Frequently Asked Questions

  • Terms & Conditions

Credit Center

  • TSC Credit Card

  • Klarna

Stay Connected

Connect & Share with the Tractor Supply Community.

Tractor Supply App

Shop on the go with the Tractor Supply App

Learn More

Stay Connected

Connect & Share with the Tractor Supply Community.

Tractor Supply App

Shop on the go with the Tractor Supply App

Learn More
  • Order Status

  • Return Policy

  • Delivery Options

  • Tax Exemptions

  • Frequently Asked Questions

  • Contact Us

  • Recall Notices

  • Call:  (877) 718-6750

  • Mon - Sat: 7am - 9pm CT

  • Sun: 8am - 7pm CT

  • Closed Christmas Day

  • Who We Are

  • Investor Relations

  • Stewardship

  • Community

  • Military Support

  • Product Catalog

  • Tractor Supply Stores

  • .Pharmacy Verified Website

  • Careers

  • Sponsorship

  • Affiliate Program

  • Potential Vendor Partners

  • Vendor Information

  • Tractor Supply Media Network

  • About

  • Rewards

  • Hometown Heroes

  • Frequently Asked Questions

  • Terms & Conditions

  • TSC Credit Card

  • Klarna

Connect & Share with the Tractor Supply Community.

Shop on the go with the Tractor Supply App

Learn More
  • Privacy policy
  • Your Privacy Choices
  • Terms and Conditions
  • California Transparency Act
  • Legal Notices
  • Accessibility
  • Responsible Disclosure Statement
  • Surprise (Balance) Medical Billing Disclosure
  • Transparency in Coverage
  • Human Rights Policy
  • Vendor Code of Conduct
  • California Notice of Collection
  • Privacy Requests

© 2026, Tractor Supply Co. All Rights Reserved.