These seem to be decent boots. Have only worn them twice so far. But, don't go by the "True Fit" recommendation. I did, and it is off. First of all it claims these run small. Don't believe that, they do not. I bought them a half size bigger than what I wear, and they are huge. They don't offer half sizes, and I can't go down a full size. These boots are also extremely heavy. I haven't checked them for water tightness yet, so I can't say if they are good there. I did wear them on a day that the temperature was in the low 40s, high 30s. My feet were not freezing, so the insulation seems to be good.