Quality was fine. "Red duck" color was chocolate brown. I like this liner. Fabric weight was good, hood fit well, zipper seemed nice. I'm 5'9", 180#, 34" sleeve, 16" neck, 41" chest, 32" waist, 38" hips. (Telecom tower climber, I'm a little ball of muscle, hate, and coffee.) The sleeves were perfect, good length, just loose enough to wear base layer+flannel+hoody and still move but zero extra, sleeves still covered my wrists when I lifted my hands above my head and the jacket has underarm gussets in addition to the action-back so no issues crossing my arms or anything. Shoulder width was perfect, seemed to be about 19" seam to seam across the top, which leaves room for layering without having the jacket restrict movement. The knit bottom of the body to seal out the draft seemed like it was fine for my hips, would fit someone 36-42" hips. Not going to fit very big guys. The underarm chest measurement was 23" across, baggy for layering and movement, fit my chest a tad but big but ok. The waist measurement was 25" across, so a 50" waist. I have a 32" waist. I could completely double the jacket over the entire front of my body and still had room to move. This jacket would fit your redneck drunk uncle's beer belly with room to spare. This jacket would fit two of me at the waist. The body length: jacket came down to the bottom of the pockets on my pants, I'm 5'9", jacket feels like it was sized to fit people up to 6'2" (like the model in the photos)and every inch shorter than that means it will look longer and longer, can't just roll the bottom up because the zipper makes a weird lump. Overall, even though the shoulders and sleeves fit right, just too much fabric and had to return it. It gave "I'm in grade school and wearing my dad's jacket" vibes. For reference I wear an old size Medium M-65 field jacket and it fits fine without the liner, just enough room to button in the smoking jacket and wear a collared shirt. And I wear a medium peacoat.

Very warm and comfortable. Full swing adds great maneuverability. 6'2 260lbs in a 2x

The jacket was excellent, but too large. I gave it to my daughter.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] More than what I expected, The Red Duck color is very attractive. Definitely looking for a hoodie in Red Duck color.