The style, material and fit are OK, but several points don't match the website description. There is no 'sherpa-lined hood' - just a collar. The hand pockets aren't secure because they don't have fastenings, so things can fall out when you bend over (as I discovered), and although the internal chest pocket does fasten it's much too small for a phone. Overall these issues make the gilet less useful

I love this vest is gives me the perfect amount of warmth for fall and goes with all my clothes. Definitely reccomend!

The gilet fits well and seems warm. The missing stars are because the description isn't accurate. There's no 'sherpa-lined stretch hood' - just a high collar. Also it doesn't have 'zippered hand and chest pockets'. The single outer chest.pocket is the only one with a zip - the hand pockets don't have any fastenings. There is an internal pocket - with velcro fastening - but it's too small for my phone. Overall a bit disappointing because of those issues

I have a couple of these in varying colors, when they fit, they're fantastic. Super warm, tons of pockets, and the collar doesn't get in the way. The sizing is a little inconsistent but it's not terrible, for the most part fairly true to size. I have a couple that are all the same size but in reality they vary a bit, some are a little snug and some have enough room for a heavy hoodie underneath. The stichings comes loose and a little crooked sometimes but since that's mostly been cosmetic so far I can look past it.